Story audio is generated using AI
Eastern Cape education department communications director Vuyiseka Aviwe Mboxela says she is ready to return to work after being cleared of disciplinary charges brought against her.
In a ruling dated October 21, disciplinary inquiry chairperson MP Mhlanti found that the department had failed to prove the allegations against Mboxela on a balance of probabilities.
The ruling found her not guilty of all six charges and ordered that they be removed from her personal file and records.
The six charges included allegations that Mboxela had victimised and marginalised deputy director Malibongwe Mtima, bullied staff and abused her authority, misused managerial discretion, acted unprofessionally, committed insubordination and engaged in improper public communications, including the alleged unauthorised use of a departmental letterhead.
Mboxela told TimesLIVE she was happy to be back at work because it would allow her to serve the people of the province.
“As a person, l have learnt a great deal that sometimes in life you can fall in a sword of your humanity and be proven later after your image has been completely destroyed [sic],” she said.
What kept her going was the work of journalists who refused to report one-sided stories, she said.
“Today my name is cleared.”
Mboxela alleged that the charges had no basis from the beginning and that she had been made a “sacrificial lamb” to protect relations between the National Education, Health and Allied Workers’ Union (Nehawu) and the department’s top management.
In explaining the finding of not guilty, Mhlanti said: “A disciplinary finding must be based upon evidence and reasonable inference, not suspicion.
“Where the evidence leaves material matters unresolved, the employer has not discharged the balance-of-probabilities standard.”
On the allegations of bullying and victimisation, the chairperson found that workplace conflict and disagreements were not enough on their own to establish misconduct. The evidence did not sufficiently show that Mboxela had deliberately used her managerial authority to target Mtima.
The inquiry also considered allegations involving staff claims, travel and subsistence expenses, leave and work allocation. The ruling noted that important supporting documents were missing and that some decisions could have had operational or management explanations.
On the allegations of unprofessional conduct, the chairperson found that “material inconsistencies and insufficiently corroborated allegations prevent a finding that the alleged conduct has been established”.
The department also failed to prove that Mboxela had deliberately and wilfully defied an instruction.
Regarding public communications and social media, the ruling found that the evidence did not sufficiently establish the precise statements made, their full context or the workplace rules allegedly breached.
The chairperson also found that the evidence did not sufficiently establish the required guilty intention in relation to the alleged unauthorised use of a departmental letterhead.
For Mboxela, the outcome brings the inquiry to an end after a process she says affected her reputation. She said the experience had taught her difficult lessons about how a person could be judged before being cleared.
“What matters most for me now is that I have peace with them because I know myself more than them,” she said.
TimesLIVE
Gugulethu Mashinini
www.timeslive.co.za
