Mpumalanga health held fully liable for child’s cerebral palsy after 2009 birth injury

The Mpumalanga Department of Health has been held fully liable for the damages suffered by a child who sustained a brain injury during his birth at Piet Retief Hospital in 2009.

The High Court in Mbombela found that inadequate foetal monitoring during labour amounted to negligence and caused the child’s cerebral palsy.

Acting Judge President Takalani Vincent Ratshibvumo ruled in a claim brought by the child’s mother against the MEC of Health in Mpumalanga.

The mother sued both in her personal capacity and on behalf of her son, who was born in November 2009.

The claim, initially valued at approximately R16 million, arose from alleged medical negligence during labour and delivery. The court was asked to determine liability only, with the assessment of damages postponed to a later stage.

According to the judgment, the pregnancy had been uncomplicated, and both mother and baby were considered healthy during antenatal care.

The mother was admitted to Piet Retief Hospital in November 2009 with labour pains. She later testified that, after an initial period of monitoring, there were long periods during which she did not recall being assessed.

She eventually gave birth by forceps at about 4.15am on 19 November.

She told the court that her baby did not cry immediately after birth. Nurses slapped his feet in an attempt to stimulate him, and she said the first cry she heard was more than an hour later and sounded like a “squeaking sound”.

The baby also struggled to breastfeed and subsequently required feeding through a nasogastric tube. He remained in hospital for about a week and was cared for in an incubator.

The judgment records that since he was born, the child has never sat, stood, walked or spoken.

He has been completely dependent on his mother for activities such as eating and bathing and had suffered seizures requiring medication.

Medical evidence later established that he had spastic quadriparesis cerebral palsy, microcephaly, profound intellectual disability and epilepsy.

Critical monitoring gaps

A central issue in the case was the hospital’s failure to properly monitor and record the condition of the mother and foetus during labour.

The court heard that the mother entered the active phase of labour at about 8pm on 18 November. Under the applicable maternity guidelines, the foetal heart rate should then have been monitored every 30 minutes.

Instead, the records did not demonstrate that the required monitoring had taken place.

More importantly, the mother was fully dilated by 2am on 19 November, but the child was only delivered by forceps more than two hours later.

The court described this period as a critical stage of labour, yet there were no records of foetal monitoring during the two hours and 15 minutes between full dilation and delivery.

The plaintiff’s obstetric expert, Dr Constant Ndjapa-Ndamkou, testified that this amounted to a significant departure from the required standard of care.

He said the lack of monitoring created a risk that developing foetal hypoxia would go undetected.

The hospital’s own expert, Dr Peter Koll, conceded that the recording of monitoring was substandard. His position, however, was that poor record-keeping did not necessarily mean the monitoring itself had not been performed.

He argued that nurses could have been monitoring the foetal heart rate without recording every observation, particularly during the second stage of labour.

The court ultimately rejected this argument in the circumstances of the case.

Experts divided over when the brain injury occurred

The most important dispute was not whether the child had suffered a brain injury, but when that injury occurred.

The plaintiff’s paediatric neurologist, Professor Regan Shane Solomons, testified that an MRI scan showed a partial prolonged hypoxic-ischaemic injury.

He linked the injury to a lack of oxygen and blood supply around the time of birth and excluded other potential causes, including infections, metabolic disorders and congenital abnormalities.

The plaintiff’s neonatologist, Professor Victor Allan Davies, similarly concluded that the injury was consistent with repeated episodes of hypoxia during labour.

He pointed to the child’s poor feeding, seizures and lethargy as signs of neonatal encephalopathy.

The defence experts took a different view.

Professor Daynia Ballot argued that the child did not have hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy at birth. She relied heavily on the recorded Apgar scores of 9/10 and 10/10, the absence of documented resuscitation and the fact that the child appeared clinically well immediately after birth.

She placed particular emphasis on the fact that the child became seriously ill about 50 hours after birth. In her view, an intrapartum hypoxic injury would have manifested much earlier.

She accepted that the MRI showed a hypoxic brain injury but maintained that the scan could not establish when the injury occurred.

Court criticises reliability of Apgar score

Judge Ratshibvumo ultimately found the defence’s reliance on the Apgar scores problematic.

The court noted that both sides’ experts accepted that an Apgar score could not, on its own, establish whether a baby had suffered birth asphyxia.

The score provides a snapshot of the newborn’s condition at a particular moment, while an umbilical cord blood test would have provided additional information about the baby’s metabolic state. No such test had been performed in this case.

The court was also troubled by the lack of detail showing how the recorded Apgar scores had been calculated.

The mother’s evidence that the baby did not cry immediately and required stimulation was not contradicted by the staff who attended the delivery.

The judge therefore found that the apparently perfect Apgar scores could have been recorded incorrectly or could have represented only a rough assessment.

The court further rejected the suggestion that the mother’s observations could simply be dismissed because she was an inexperienced young mother.

Judge Ratshibvumo found her evidence about the baby’s twitching, eye movements and inability to suckle to be direct and uncontroverted.

The judge said those observations were consistent with the medical evidence concerning evolving neonatal encephalopathy.

Missing records counted against the department

A significant part of the court’s reasoning concerned the consequences of inadequate medical records.

The defence argued that the absence of entries did not necessarily mean that monitoring had not occurred.

However, the judge found it difficult to accept this position where the hospital’s own experts had conceded that the record-keeping and monitoring documentation were “undeniably substandard”.

The court said it was contradictory to rely heavily on the reliability of the hospital’s Apgar scores and postnatal assessments while simultaneously acknowledging that the same staff had failed to comply with mandatory monitoring and recording requirements during labour.

The judgment concluded that, where there was no evidence demonstrating that proper monitoring had taken place, the court could safely conclude that there had been no monitoring during the periods not reflected in the records.

Court finds negligence caused the injury

In determining causation, the court applied the “but-for” test, asking whether the injury would probably have been avoided had proper monitoring taken place.

The judge stressed that the purpose of regular foetal monitoring was to detect foetal distress early enough for medical intervention.

The court found that hospital staff had a duty to monitor the foetal heart rate every 30 minutes during the active phase of labour and more frequently during the second stage.

That duty was particularly important during the prolonged period after the mother became fully dilated.

The argument that a normal CTG reading shortly before the forceps delivery cleared the department was rejected.

The court held that a single reading could not establish that the foetus had remained well during the preceding unmonitored period.

Had proper monitoring been performed, the court found, developing hypoxia would probably have been detected and earlier intervention — including an earlier forceps delivery or emergency Caesarean section — could have prevented the prolonged hypoxic injury.

The judge concluded that the plaintiff’s experts had presented a logical and medically coherent chain of events: inadequate monitoring resulted in undetected foetal distress during a prolonged second stage of labour, which caused a hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury that manifested as neonatal encephalopathy and ultimately resulted in cerebral palsy.

Department ordered to pay 100% of damages

The court found that the plaintiff had proved her case on a balance of probabilities.

The MEC for Health, Mpumalanga Province, was consequently declared liable for 100% of the agreed or proven damages arising from the child’s hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury and resultant cerebral palsy.

The department was also ordered to pay the plaintiff’s costs relating to the merits of the case, including the qualifying, preparation and attendance fees of her expert witnesses.

The actual amount of compensation has not yet been determined. The court postponed the assessment of damages sine die, meaning that the quantum proceedings will take place separately at a later stage.

[email protected]

IOL News

Get your news on the go. Download the latest IOL App for Android and IOS now.

Sinenhlanhla Masilela
iol.co.za

Scroll to Top